Skip to content

SEC Charges Two Promoters, Salesperson in $64 Million Offering Fraud

By Mari Nicholson

SEC Charges Two Promoters, Salesperson in $64 Million Offering Fraud

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filed fraud charges Sept. 11 against Paul Thomas Croft, Jonathan David Frost, and Matthew William Dira, alleging the three ran a multiyear scheme that raised approximately $64 million from more than 230 investors through the sale of promissory notes and limited liability company membership interests. The complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee, Southern Division.

Croft and Frost jointly owned Croft & Frost, PLLC, a Chattanooga, Tenn., accounting and tax-preparation firm. Between January 2021 and September 2023, according to the complaint, the two operated through the firm and a network of LLCs including the Well Fund, the Scorpio Fund, the Taurus Fund, the Capricorn Fund, the Chestnut Fund, and the Gemini Fund, telling investors their money would fund real estate purchases, small-business loans, or an apartment building acquisition. The notes carried stated annual returns ranging from 7% to 360%, with terms as short as two months and as long as eight years.

Another entity, Rhino Onward, operated differently. According to the complaint, Croft and Frost formed Rhino Onward in early 2022 purportedly to construct and operate a hydrogen power plant, despite neither having any knowledge or expertise in the hydrogen power industry. Rather than sell notes directly, they created four separate “ROI Funds” – LLCs that sold membership interests to investors under membership interest purchase agreements, typically signed by Frost, representing that each ROI Fund existed solely to fund a $10 million loan to Rhino Onward. Each ROI Fund’s operating agreement said the fund was formed to generate a one-time profit from funding a $10 million equity infusion for Rhino Onward and would “not engage in any business activity not necessary or incidental to such purpose,” the complaint says. Between December 2022 and July 2023, Croft and Frost, either directly or through sales personnel including Dira, raised more than $8.7 million from more than 50 investors across the four ROI Funds, according to the complaint.

The ROI Fund structure gave investors little practical say even on paper, the complaint alleges. The operating agreements called for unanimous member approval of fund business generally and majority approval for any transaction outside the ordinary course, but also let members delegate day-to-day management to an operating manager, a role Frost held from the start. In practice, the SEC alleges, ROI Fund investors were never given an opportunity to vote on fund business, and Croft and Frost, who were both authorized signatories on Rhino Onward’s bank account, retained complete control over the funds’ accounts and activities. Rhino Onward took no substantial steps toward constructing a power plant, according to the complaint, which alleges Croft and Frost transferred nearly all of the ROI Funds’ investor money to Croft & Frost, PLLC for payroll and loan payments – the same pattern the complaint describes across the note-based funds.

In total, the SEC alleges, Croft and Frost diverted at least $53 million of the $64 million raised: about $33 million went to Croft & Frost, PLLC to cover payroll, commissions, and short-term loan payments; about $11 million was misappropriated for personal spending, including a Maserati, a Ferrari, and residences in Chicago and Miami, along with credit card bills for custom suits, jewelry, private flights, and yacht charters; and about $10 million funded Ponzi-style payments to earlier investors. By the time the scheme collapsed in September 2023, Croft and Frost owed investors approximately $53 million, according to the complaint.

The complaint cites internal text messages it says show the two men discussing the misuse of funds, including an April 2022 exchange in which Frost told Croft he needed to “hit the pavement” to raise money for the Scorpio Fund, and Croft asked what happened to nearly $2.1 million recently raised; Frost replied, “Yes but that’s for us bro,” according to the complaint.

Dira, who worked for Croft & Frost, PLLC as a securities salesperson and administrator, continued selling promissory notes even after receiving emails in September 2022 warning that Croft and Frost were likely running a Ponzi scheme, the SEC alleges. Dira earned more than $500,000 in salary and commissions between 2021 and 2023, including more than $235,000 after receiving those warnings, according to the complaint.

The SEC charges Croft and Frost with violating Section 17(a) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rule 10b-5, and charges Dira with violating Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act and Section 15(a)(1) of the Exchange Act, the unregistered-broker provision. Frost has consented to a bifurcated judgment, subject to court approval, that would permanently enjoin him from violating the charged provisions and from participating in the issuance, offer, or sale of any security other than for his own personal accounts, with disgorgement, prejudgment interest, and a civil penalty to be determined later by the court. The case continues against Croft and Dira.

Frost separately pleaded guilty Feb. 11 to criminal conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit money laundering, and conspiracy to defraud the United States in a parallel case, United States v. Jonathan D. Frost, No. 1:26-cr-00004-TRM-CHS, based largely on the same conduct alleged in the SEC’s complaint.

Visit the AltsWire directory page.