Skip to content

IPA, ADISA, and Stanger Press SEC to Preempt State Blue-Sky Review

By Mari Nicholson

IPA, ADISA, and Stanger Press SEC to Preempt State Blue-Sky Review

The public comment period on the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s Registered Offering Reform proposal closed Monday, drawing supportive letters from Robert A. Stanger & Co., the Alternative & Direct Investment Securities Association, or ADISA, and a 15-organization trade coalition whose signatories include ADISA and the Institute for Portfolio Alternatives. Stanger’s letter put the cost of state blue-sky review at 10 to 13 basis points of capital raised and the average delay to clearance at 7.3 months.

AltsWire covered the initial proposal in May. The proposal would redefine “qualified purchaser” under Rule 146 to treat any investor in an SEC-registered offering as a qualified purchaser, making the securities sold in that offering covered securities and preempting state registration and qualification review – known as blue-sky review – for registered offerings, including those of nontraded real estate investment trusts and business development companies. States would retain antifraud enforcement authority and certain notice-filing and fee powers under Section 18(c) of the Securities Act of 1933.

IPA has pressed the commission on preemption since before the proposal was issued. President and chief executive officer Anya Coverman wrote in a June 4 op-ed for AltsWire that nontraded REITs and BDCs are “nearly the only SEC-registered offerings still carrying that burden” of state merit review, and that the number of U.S. public companies has fallen 40% since the 1990s. An investor can put an entire portfolio into a single technology stock, she wrote, “yet a state may forbid that same investor from placing more than a sliver of it in a diversified REIT or BDC.”

Coverman drew a parallel to mutual funds, which once cleared state-by-state review under what she called a “crazy quilt” of conflicting rules until the National Securities Markets Improvement Act of 1996, or NSMIA, preempted that review. Citing Stanger data, she wrote that publicly registered nontraded REIT fundraising fell from $33.2 billion in 2022 to $5.7 billion in 2025 while private placement REIT fundraising rose from $1.4 billion to $9.6 billion, lifting private placements from about 4% to roughly 63% of nontraded REIT capital raised. The commission’s proposal, she wrote, is “the most serious step toward fixing the problem in two decades.”

Stanger’s Kevin T. Gannon, chairman and chief executive officer, filed an individual letter July 23 drawing on the firm’s own sponsor and law-firm surveys. Gannon said a survey of 12 sponsors representing funds that raised more than $25.8 billion during the past three years found blue-sky compliance costs of 10 to 13 basis points of capital raised, rising to 20 to 30 basis points for smaller funds. A separate survey of seven law firms representing more than 41 funds put the average incremental delay for blue-sky clearance at 7.3 months.

Gannon said he expects that no new publicly registered nontraded REITs or BDCs will come to market in 2026 because of blue-sky-related friction. “The alternative investment market deserves this change on the preemption matter,” Gannon said.

ADISA’s July 27 letter, drafted by a committee chaired by Catherine Bowman, cited the same Stanger data to argue the shift toward private placements has already taken hold: registered nontraded REIT issuers fell from 44 in 2015, when they raised $10 billion, to 20 in the first quarter of 2026, raising $1.8 billion for the quarter, while the number of private placement REIT issuers grew from one in 2015 to 25 in the first quarter of 2026.

ADISA also urged the commission to apply preemption broadly across security types rather than carving out exceptions, and to issue transition guidance covering pending offerings, notice filings and multi-security programs. Removing duplicative state qualification review “may reverse this trend and move more capital raising back into the registered market,” the letter said.

The joint trades letter, signed by 15 organizations including ADISA, IPA, Nareit, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, framed the proposal as a continuation of NSMIA and the JOBS Act of 2012 rather than a break from precedent. “This principle is rooted in the original design of the federal securities laws,” the coalition wrote, arguing that registered securities are national by nature and that duplicative state review makes the registered path “harder to use and, in turn, less available” to retail investors.

IPA’s Coverman separately summarized the argument: “a public offering should be able to reach investors through a single federal registration process. The market needs one front door, not 53.”

With the comment window now closed, the SEC will review submissions before deciding whether to adopt, modify, or withdraw the proposal – a process with no fixed timeline.

Visit the AltsWire directory page.