Skip to content

ExchangeRight’s First Fast-Track DST Exits to REIT With 6.01% Return

By Mari Nicholson

Image featuring the two tenants of Essential Income 2 DST: Sherwin-Williams and Dollar General
Photo courtesy of ExchangeRight

ExchangeRight has taken the first offering in its REIT Fast-Track Delaware statutory trust series full cycle, moving Essential Income 2 DST, a $2.13 million, two-property portfolio, into its nontraded Essential Income REIT on Nov. 9 through a tax-deferred Section 721 exchange.

The Pasadena, Calif.-based sponsor said the exit, its 35th full-cycle event, returned 100% of investor capital and produced total net annual returns of 6.01%, in line with the 6% total cash flow projected at inception. ExchangeRight told AltsWire the figure reflects monthly distributions over the hold period plus the return of investors’ original capital at exit.

The real estate investment trust paid 100% of the DST investors’ original investment for the portfolio, which holds one property in Missouri and one in Ohio, according to ExchangeRight. The company said KPMG valued the portfolio independently beforehand to confirm the acquisition would be accretive to the REIT’s net asset value.

Essential Income DSTs are structured to pay monthly income over a targeted two-year hold, after which investors exchange their interests for units in the REIT’s operating partnership. Unlike other ExchangeRight DST series, the Essential Income offerings do not provide a 1031 exchange option at exit. All Essential Income 2 interests were exchanged for the REIT’s Class A 721 operating partnership units, which carry redemption rights, and ExchangeRight said investors can seek liquidity through the REIT’s quarterly share repurchase program.

Essential Income 2 DST launched and was fully subscribed on Nov. 8, 2024, the company said. According to ExchangeRight, it filled before Essential Income 1 DST, which is why it exited first; the company’s May 2025 announcement had described Essential Income 1 as the first fully subscribed offering in the series. ExchangeRight fully subscribed the $30.68 million Essential Income 10 DST in November, after it closed the $52.85 million Essential Income 9 DST in September.

Joshua Ungerecht, a managing partner at ExchangeRight, described the full-cycle event as part of the company’s aggregation strategy, “illustrating how our DST and REIT investment solutions are designed to work together for the benefit of investors.”

The 6.01% return lowered ExchangeRight’s average annual total return across its 35 full-cycle offerings to 8.53%, net of fees, from the 8.60% it had reported across 34 offerings. The company said the figure is a simple average, so each offering counts equally regardless of size. When ExchangeRight announced it had taken its 34th offering full cycle in December 2024, the $117.1 million Net-Leased Portfolio 28 DST produced total net annual returns of 6.96% to 9.02%, the company said at the time.

The Receiving REIT

Essential Income REIT owned 475 properties in 39 states as of Sept. 30, up from 436 properties in 38 states three months earlier. The portfolio was 98.4% leased to 44 tenants, which the company describes as primarily investment-grade. ExchangeRight said its adjusted funds from operations-to-distribution coverage ratio was 102.92% from inception through Sept. 30. The REIT had raised $550.3 million in its continuous private offering as of Oct. 31 and declared a monthly dividend of $0.1449 per share for October.

Separately, ExchangeRight said it and its affiliates surpassed $8 billion in assets under management as of Oct. 31, reporting more than $8.1 billion across more than 1,400 properties and 33 million square feet in 47 states. The firm reported more than $7.7 billion as of July 31.

The company said it has returned more than $2.6 billion in distributions, capital, and gains to investors since inception, up from more than $2.4 billion as of Dec. 31, 2025. ExchangeRight said its portfolios are now net leased to 102 tenants in 20 industries it describes as necessity-based, including Amazon, Kroger, FedEx, and Walmart, and it has closed $878 million in acquisitions so far this year after reviewing more than 10,000 opportunities.

The milestone release also pointed to the REIT’s October purchase of the Dow Texas Innovation Center, a 664,100-square-foot research and development campus in Lake Jackson, Texas, leased to The Dow Chemical Company and acquired through a 721 exchange.

For more ExchangeRight news, visit its directory page.