Skip to content

Bankruptcy Judge Rejects Claimants’ Bid to Narrow Inspired Healthcare Freeze

By Mari Nicholson

Bankruptcy Judge Rejects Claimants' Bid to Narrow Inspired Healthcare Freeze

A bankruptcy judge has turned away a renewed attempt to narrow the injunction shielding Inspired Healthcare Capital’s broker-dealers and former chief executive officer Luke Lee from FINRA arbitration claims, ruling in a Sept. 16 order that the freeze’s own language already answers the question claimants were asking the court to clarify.

The order, entered in the adversary proceeding Inspired Healthcare Capital Holdings, LLC v. Aurora Securities, et al., denies an emergency motion filed by counsel for claimants in 66 separate FINRA arbitrations – a coalition of six law firms including Soriede Law Group, The White Law Group, Wolper Law Firm, and Klayman Toskes – along with a joinder from a separate group of individual claimants represented by Whitaker Chalk.

The dispute traces back to a preliminary injunction Judge Mark X. Mullin granted on July 24, freezing more than 100 FINRA arbitration claims against Inspired Healthcare’s broker-dealer network and Lee, whom that order identifies as the company’s “former CEO.” That injunction followed a temporary restraining order AltsWire reported on July 1 and a hearing at which the judge deferred ruling by nearly a week while the court sorted out sealed exhibits and competing timelines. The July 24 order stays – through Nov. 21, 2026 – any FINRA arbitration claim tied to the purchase of Inspired Healthcare’s own investment fund or Delaware statutory trust securities, what the order calls “IHC investment-related claims.”

The problem, according to the claimants who brought this latest motion, is that many of the more than 100 frozen arbitrations bundle IHC-related claims together with separate, unrelated claims against the same broker-dealers – allegations that have nothing to do with Inspired Healthcare’s own securities. They asked the court to clarify that only the IHC-specific portions of those mixed claims are on hold, freeing the rest to proceed.

In his Sept. 16 order, Judge Mullin said the point was already settled: a footnote in the original July 24 injunction states that nothing in the order prohibits any IHC investor from pursuing non-IHC related causes of action against a non-debtor defendant, and that footnote “qualifies the entire ‘preliminary injunction order.’” Attached to the Sept. 16 order as an exhibit is an Aug. 28 order reaching the same substantive conclusion and laying out a mechanism for sorting the mixed claims – a claim-by-claim chart distinguishing stayed from unstayed allegations within a single arbitration, to be filed under seal rather than made public.

The ruling leaves the broader fight over the injunction itself untouched. Two claimant groups – the Whitaker Chalk-represented claimants who joined this latest motion, and the Soriede-led, 66-arbitration coalition – have already appealed the July 24 injunction to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, consolidated as Civil Action 4:26-cv-00974-P, arguing, among 15 grounds, that the bankruptcy court lacked authority to enjoin arbitration claims against non-debtor parties in the first place.

The Sept. 16 order notes that appeal explicitly, and makes clear the pending appeal doesn’t affect the stay: the stay remains in effect through Nov. 21 “unless and until the preliminary injunction order is modified by the bankruptcy court or by an appellate court.”

Lee, who stepped down as chief executive around the time of the February bankruptcy filing, remains one of the named parties shielded by the injunction alongside the broker-dealer defendants. He also faces a separate line of scrutiny in the bankruptcy itself. As AltsWire reported in August, the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors has demanded his bank and tax records as part of a broader investigation into his personal finances, while he seeks to have the company’s own insurance cover his legal bills. That fight over Lee’s financial exposure is working its way through the bankruptcy court on its own schedule, distinct from the FINRA-claims freeze at issue here.

Visit the AltsWire directory page.