DOL Rescinds 2024 Independent Contractor Rule, Restores ‘Core Factor’ Test

The U.S. Department of Labor on Nov. 19 announced a final rule that rescinds its 2024 test for classifying workers as employees or independent contractors and replaces it with a “core factor” analysis similar to the framework it adopted in 2021. The Financial Services Institute, or FSI, which represents independent financial advisers and independent broker-dealers, had pressed for the change.
The rule takes effect 60 days after publication in the Federal Register. The version released Nov. 19 has cleared White House regulatory review and is pending publication.
“This rule strikes the right balance by protecting employees who are entitled to the protections of federal wage and hour laws, while also respecting the entrepreneurial spirit of legitimate independent contractors,” said Andrew Rogers, administrator of the department’s Wage and Hour Division.
Two Core Factors
The rule governs worker classification under the Fair Labor Standards Act and, through conforming amendments, the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act. The ultimate question is whether a worker is, as a matter of economic reality, in business for himself or herself or economically dependent on a potential employer for work.
Two core factors, the nature and degree of control over the work and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss, are the most probative. If both point to the same classification, the rule says there is a “substantial likelihood” that classification is accurate. Three other factors – the skill the work requires, the permanence of the working relationship, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production – carry less weight.
The rule also says the parties’ actual practice matters more than what is contractually or theoretically possible. A worker’s theoretical ability to work for competitors means less if the worker is prevented from doing so in practice, and a business’s contractual authority to supervise means little if it never exercises it.
The 2024 rule used a six-factor, totality-of-the-circumstances test in which no single factor or group of factors was necessarily decisive. It took effect March 11, 2024. The department’s Wage and Hour Division stopped applying it in enforcement on May 1, 2025, and four of five lawsuits challenging it remain pending, though stayed.
Compliance Requirements and Control
Under the control factor, requiring a worker to comply with specific legal obligations, satisfy health and safety standards, carry insurance, or meet contractually agreed-upon deadlines or quality control standards “does not constitute control” that makes the worker more or less likely to be an employee. The 2024 rule excluded only actions taken “for the sole purpose” of complying with a specific law and said steps beyond that could indicate control.
The final rule adds that a requirement is judged by its substance and practical operation, not its stated purpose. Detailed instructions on how, when, or where work is done may still indicate employment even if described as safety or quality control measures.
The department declined requests from business groups, including the American Securities Association, to add industry-specific text or examples, saying the rule is meant to apply generally. Responding to the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, which raised financial advisers’ use of a broker-dealer’s platform to effect securities transactions, the department said the relevance of a worker’s use of a business’s technology depends on the circumstances of each case.
FSI Reaction
FSI said the rule restores an approach that helps preserve independent financial advisers’ independent contractor status and clarifies that compliance with legal obligations such as securities laws and regulations does not constitute control.
“This rule recognizes the realities of the independent business model and protects advisors’ ability to operate independently while ensuring Main Street investors continue to have access to affordable, professional financial advice,” said Dale Brown, president and chief executive officer at FSI.
FSI supported the proposal in an April 28 comment letter. According to the department’s summary of comments, FSI cited an Oxford Economics survey finding that up to a fifth of independent financial advisers would potentially retire if reclassified as employees, and said keeping the 2024 rule would raise the cost of retirement planning and other financial guidance. FSI opposed the 2024 rule when it was released in January 2024 and later joined a lawsuit challenging it.
From Proposal to Final Rule
The department proposed the change in February and received about 16,500 comments during a 60-day period that ended April 28. Of those, 14,244 were campaign submissions from seven organized initiatives, all supporting the rulemaking. The final rule includes 14 illustrative examples, six of them new, involving digital platform workers, farm labor contractors, and truck drivers.
The department estimates the rule will produce $694.8 million in net cost savings a year, against $495.7 million in first-year regulatory familiarization costs, and that the share of workers who are independent contractors could rise by 1 to 3 percentage points.
The rule does not change how employee or independent contractor status is assessed under other federal laws, including the Internal Revenue Code, and does not preempt state or local laws.


