Skip to content

FS Credit REIT Non-Accruals Nearly Triple to $653M; Returns Turn Negative

By Mari Nicholson

Board members sitting at a desk several feet from bags of money
Photo courtesy of iStock Images

FS Credit Real Estate Income Trust Inc. ended the third quarter with $652.8 million of loans on non-accrual status, nearly triple the $219.5 million at the end of 2025 and about double the $322.7 million at June 30, after the nontraded mortgage real estate investment trust stopped accruing interest on a $358.8 million multifamily loan in September. The REIT, which has about $3 billion in net asset value, or NAV, also took back five apartment properties through foreclosure in July and August.

The credit pressure arrived alongside the end of a long performance run. All seven of the REIT’s share classes posted negative total returns in September and again in October, closing out what the company had described as 77 consecutive months of positive total returns through August.

Lowest-Rated Loans More Than Quadruple

As of Sept. 30, five loans with a combined amortized cost of $535.7 million, or 6% of the loan portfolio, carried the trust’s lowest internal risk rating of 5, which it assigns when an impairment or loss is likely or foreclosure is probable. At year-end, four loans totaling $120.5 million, or 2% of the book, held that rating. Loans rated 4, the next-riskiest category, rose to $658.6 million from $491.9 million.

The largest of the risk-5 loans is a $358.8 million senior loan originated in June 2022 and secured by multifamily properties in multiple locations, which moved to non-accrual in September. Two senior loans on multifamily properties in Houston and Mesquite, Texas, with a combined amortized cost of $117.7 million, moved to cost-recovery accounting in July and carry $5.7 million of specific reserves. The other two are a $35 million San Francisco office loan on non-accrual since September 2024 and a $22.5 million hotel loan in Gaithersburg, Md., on non-accrual since January 2025.

In all, loans 90 or more days past due totaled $896.3 million at Sept. 30, up from $437.1 million at year-end. That includes $243.5 million of loans that were at least 90 days past due on interest but had not been placed on non-accrual, down from $308.4 million at year-end.

In July and August, the REIT acquired five multifamily properties through foreclosure in Sandy Springs and Roswell, Ga.; Aurora, Colo.; and Arlington and Austin, Texas, recording them at a combined value of $241.3 million. It charged off $6.9 million tied to the Austin and Roswell loans.

The trust’s current expected credit loss, or CECL, reserve on its loan portfolio stood at $48.5 million at Sept. 30, down from $77.3 million at year-end and $69.9 million at June 30. In the third quarter, a $27.1 million reduction in general reserves outweighed $12.6 million of new specific reserves on impaired loans. The REIT said the reserve reduction over the first nine months of the year was driven primarily by the macroeconomic assumptions it uses to set its general reserve.

Quarterly Earnings Fall by Half

Net income attributable to the REIT was $30.3 million in the third quarter, down from $59.8 million a year earlier, even with a $14.7 million net credit-loss benefit from the lower reserve. The year-earlier quarter included a $15.8 million benefit. Net interest income fell to $45.9 million from $66.3 million. Modified funds from operations declined to $29.7 million from $47.6 million.

Lending picked up. The trust funded $609.2 million of loans in the quarter, compared with $54.7 million in the third quarter of 2025, and said it closed three loans totaling about $284.2 million in commitments in October.

NAV Slips Across Share Classes

Net asset value per share as of Oct. 31 ranged from $23.2952 for Class Y shares to $24.6152 for Class F shares, with Class S at $24.2255, Class D at $24.0105, Class M at $24.0846, Class T at $23.9531, and Class I at $23.3179. Each class was 2.1% to 2.2% below its June 30 NAV, according to an AltsWire calculation. Total NAV was $2.98 billion across 125.1 million shares.

September total returns ranged from negative 0.26% for Class Y to negative 0.46% for Class T. The company attributed the decline to mark-to-market losses tied to higher interest rates and higher assumed exit capitalization rates on the portfolio’s equity positions. The company said September marked the largest monthly drawdown on a total return basis for its Class I and Class S shares. October returns ranged from negative 0.13% for Class F to negative 0.33% for Class T, which the REIT attributed to unrealized depreciation in select equity positions. The company said it has posted positive total returns in 101 of 105 months since inception.

The negative months follow a January announcement in which the REIT said it would cut its distribution rate by 30 basis points across all share classes, effective with the February distribution. Monthly distributions held at the reduced level through September: $0.1300 per share for Class S and Class T shares, $0.1415 for Class D and Class M, $0.1479 for Class I, $0.1736 for Class F, and $0.1739 for Class Y.

Repurchase Demand Climbs

The trust repurchased 4,575,559 shares in the third quarter, which it said represented all requests received. September repurchases of 2,197,833 shares were roughly double July’s 1,053,957. The REIT said it met 100% of repurchase requests in October as well.

Through the first nine months of 2026, the REIT bought back 15 million shares for $367.3 million, compared with $376.4 million in the same period of 2025. In March, when requests reached 2.1% of NAV, the board approved repurchases above the plan’s 2% monthly limit so it could fill all of them, the REIT said.

FS Credit REIT is sponsored by Future Standard and sub-advised by Rialto Capital Management. The REIT launched a $2.5 billion continuous offering in June and expanded a Capital One financing facility to $750 million earlier this year. In October, it amended two Wells Fargo repurchase facilities to extend one maturity to October 2027 and, subject to conditions, another to November 2028.

For more Future Standard news, visit its directory page.