Skip to content

LPL Drops Recruiting Practice in Settlement of Ameriprise Data Dispute

By Mari Nicholson

Gavel with judge in background holding papers
Photo courtesy of iStock Images

LPL Financial and Ameriprise Financial have settled the legal battle that began in July 2024, when Ameriprise accused its rival of directing recruited advisers to take confidential client data with them. The terms are confidential, and the firms said LPL has discontinued the recruiting practice at the center of the dispute.

In a Nov. 17 filing in Ameriprise’s federal case against LPL in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California, the firms asked the court to dismiss the case with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled, with each side bearing its own costs. An LPL spokesperson said the agreement resolves both the firms’ federal court matters and their arbitration disputes before the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. No settlement amount was disclosed.

“LPL Financial and Ameriprise have reached a confidential settlement to resolve the legal matters between our firms. It is in our shared interest to move forward, and we are committed to supporting smooth and compliant transitions for advisors and clients when they occur. While there were differences of opinion about the underlying facts, LPL has discontinued the recruiting practice at issue between our firms, and we are pleased to resolve this matter,” the companies said in a joint statement.

The firms said the statement would be their only comment. It does not identify the practice. LPL had said previously that it stopped using the bulk upload tool cited in Ameriprise’s complaint at the end of 2021, AdvisorHub reported.

How the Dispute Began

Ameriprise filed suit on July 30, 2024, alleging that LPL systematically directed advisers it recruited from Ameriprise and other firms to take confidential client information when they left, in violation of the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act, securities laws, FINRA rules, and the Protocol for Broker Recruiting. The complaint alleged that recruits transferred data including Social Security numbers, account numbers, and account values, often into spreadsheets LPL provided. Ameriprise said LPL’s conduct subjected the advisers it recruited to regulatory and criminal exposure.

LPL denied the allegations, characterized the lawsuit as a public relations stunt, and said it was part of an effort to hinder competition and intimidate advisers considering a move.

On Dec. 12, 2024, U.S. District Judge Jinsook Ohta signed a stipulated order setting up a process for identifying Ameriprise client data in LPL’s possession. LPL agreed to review its systems and delete data on investors who did not follow their advisers to LPL, and to identify clients whose information came over through a bulk upload tool. The firms agreed to split the cost of a third-party forensic examiner, who would also review and image the personal devices of 30 advisers who had moved from Ameriprise to LPL, and the judge denied Ameriprise’s injunction request as moot. On Dec. 31, Ameriprise named the same advisers, who had moved to LPL between 2018 and 2021, in a FINRA arbitration. LPL later said Ameriprise wanted them to turn over their devices, personal email, and cloud storage for forensic imaging.

Data Breach Notices and Appeals

The dispute widened in April 2025, when LPL sued Ameriprise for defamation over data breach notices Ameriprise sent to clients who had followed their advisers to LPL. LPL argued the notices falsely implied clients faced identity theft risk from their own advisers; Ameriprise said it was obligated to send them and that they were substantially true. A month later, LPL dropped the suit under a court-approved agreement that required Ameriprise to identify the notified clients, limited LPL’s outreach to clients who had already moved, and preserved LPL’s damages claims for arbitration.

In August 2025, Canal View Financial Advisors, a New York team that moved to LPL in December 2019, appealed to the Ninth Circuit over an order that would have let a forensic examiner search the advisers’ personal devices. In a separate appeal filed in July 2025, 10 other advisers who had moved to LPL challenged Ohta’s denial of their bid to intervene in the case. In January 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit vacated that ruling and directed the district court to let them intervene. In May 2026, Ohta revised her order to drop the device searches because all 30 advisers had been added as parties to a FINRA arbitration hearing scheduled for October. LPL remained responsible for searching its own records.

Mixed Results in Arbitration

Individual arbitration awards gave Ameriprise limited wins. In March 2026, a FINRA panel ordered LPL and a father-son team, Mitchell and Wesley McCann, to pay Ameriprise $200,600 plus interest over breach-of-contract and recruiting claims. The McCanns were held responsible for about $183,000 and LPL for about $17,600. LPL and the McCanns denied Ameriprise’s allegations in that case. In July 2026, another panel ordered LPL and former Ameriprise adviser Adam Jurewicz to pay $16,766.21 in compensatory damages, narrower relief than Ameriprise had sought.

Ari Sonneberg, a partner at Wagner Law Group, told RIABiz that “this looks more like a pragmatic business resolution rather than a clear victory for either side.”

The settlement leaves open the broader question the case raised for independent broker-dealers: what client information advisers may take when they change firms beyond the limited contact details the Protocol for Broker Recruiting allows. The two firms regularly recruit advisers from each other.

Visit the AltsWire directory page.